Vinyl

Best Vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette

We compared our favorite vinyl products.

Vinyl

Written by Ali Fields | Updated: November 10, 2020

Best Overall Vinyl: Oracal 651

A display of the best rolls for Cricut and Silhouette, stored neatly

What We Like

  • Permanent, adhesive vinyl
  • Works for basically any project
  • Waterproof

What We Don't Like

  • Difficult to remove
  • Only comes in a glossy finish
Quick Summary

Oracal 651 remains our favorite vinyl to recommend for just about every project. It's inexpensive, comes in a load of colors, and always cuts & weeds easily. It can be difficult to remove, so I wouldn't recommend it for temporary projects like a removal decal.

A display of the best rolls for Cricut and Silhouette, stored neatly

We independently research our recommended products. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our links.

Looking for the best vinyl for your Cricut and Silhouette projects?

It’s fabulous having so many colors and textures and options, but it can also be a bit overwhelming trying to remember which one to use.

Worse, if you use the wrong kind, you could quickly ruin a project.

But fear not!

I’ll explain the different types of vinyl, exactly what they are used for, and then give you the best vinyl for every purpose and project.

The best part?

I’ve tested every vinyl to make sure it’s authentic, directly from the manufacturer and the best deal available.

I also have a few resources on how to find really cheap vinyl at the end of the article (or you can click on that link to skip ahead).

Different Types of Vinyl

So you want to know the best vinyl to get?

Well, it depends completely on what you’re planning on making. There are a few different types of vinyl, and each is best suited for different applications.

We’ll start with an easy cheat sheet I made so you can have all the important information in one place.

Cheat sheet of the best vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette, broken down by use

If you want to work with vinyl, it is so valuable to learn about the different types so you’ll always know you’re buying the right materials for the job.

I’ll explain everything, and where to buy it so that you receive the authentic product.

Best adhesive vinyl

Adhesive vinyl is regular vinyl and the most common vinyl you’ll come across.

If you got any sort of starter kit with your machine, it probably included some colorful 12 x 12 sheets of Cricut vinyl: that’s this stuff.

Like regular stickers, adhesive vinyl comes attached to a white paper backing, also known as a carrier sheet. This backing is coated in silicone, so it’s easy to pull the vinyl off. After the vinyl is cut and weeded, you use transfer tape to move it over to its final location.

There are a lot of different colors and patterns and finishes of adhesive vinyl. We’re talking hundreds of different colors, from regular rainbow hues to neon, and animal prints, chevrons, dots, stripes, you name it.

Oh, and of course we’ve got glitter vinyl, holographic vinyl, glow-in-the-dark, even chalkboard and dry erase vinyl.

There are two types of adhesive vinyl that you need to know about: removable and permanent:

Best removable (indoor) vinyl (Top choice: Oracal 631)

Vinyl bird decals on a green wall.

Removable adhesive vinyl is exactly what it sounds like: removable! It is great for indoor use, on any smooth surface that won’t need to be washed or handled too much.

The regular Cricut vinyl is this kind of removable vinyl. It typically has a matte finish, meaning it won’t glare and reflect light.

This is the vinyl that you want to use for wall decals. (It can last for years, and you can peel it off after!)

Cricut vinyl also works for smooth wooden signs, or for decorative glass and plates—as long as it stays indoors and doesn’t need to go in the dishwasher.

Actually, it’s perfect for temporary outdoor use as well, just don’t expect it to last for longer than a year. Removable vinyl is water-resistant, but not fully waterproof so it won’t survive well in tough weather.

The best removable/indoor vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette is Oracal 631.

Sale
Oracal 631 Matte Vinyl - 24 Pack of Top Colors - 12" x 12" Sheets
  • Top 24 most popular colors of oracal 631 matte vinyl
  • Each sheet is 12 inch by 12 inch
  • Vinyl is designed to last 3+ years
  • 3-mil thick

Best permanent (outdoor) vinyl (Top choice: Oracal 651)

An old-timey car covered in red and black vinyl polka dots

Permanent adhesive vinyl is, well, not actually permanent!

But it is waterproof and will last much longer than removable vinyl. (Most types are rated to last 6 years, but they can definitely stick for longer than that!)

You’ll use this vinyl for any DIY projects that need to be washed (or exposed to water/weather):

  • tumblers
  • cutting boards
  • shot glasses
  • champagne flutes
  • mason jars
  • exterior walls
  • outdoor signs
  • car decals

It also works perfectly for any interior decorations that don’t need to be removed, like on wooden signs or decorative plates. You can even use it on rough surfaces.

This vinyl is also known as sign vinyl. It has a glossy finish, meaning it is shiny and reflects light.

If you need to remove permanent vinyl, you either will use some heat (like from a hair dryer) and a lot of scraping, or an adhesive remover like Goo Gone.

The best permanent/outdoor vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette is Oracal 651.

Sale
Oracal Vinyl Sheets (63 Pack)
  • All 63 Oracal 651 colors
  • Competitive pricing - ordered/processed/distributed efficiently to keep you crafting affordably
  • Oracal 651 - high quality vinyl made in Georgia use
  • 12X 12 Sheets, professionally cut and packaged

Best heat transfer vinyl (Top choice: Siser EasyWeed Heat Transfer Vinyl)

Siser EasyWeed vinyl in a variety of pretty colors, it's the best heat transfer vinyl I've tried out

Heat transfer vinyl (HTV/iron-on vinyl) is what you’ll use for sticking vinyl to any sort of fabric. It bonds to fabric using heat and pressure.

What really matters when it comes to picking out the best heat transfer vinyl? Which is the perfect vinyl for you?

For me, it comes down to these attributes:

  • Color and finish
  • Reliability-of-cut
  • Ease-of-weeding
  • Durability
  • Price

I’ve tested + rated the 7 most popular HTV products on all of these qualities.

HTV can be applied to:

  • t-shirts
  • jackets
  • hats
  • canvas totes
  • pillows
  • flags
  • quilts
  • any cotton or polyester fabric
  • leather, spandex, and nylon (with specialty HTV)

Unlike adhesive vinyl, heat transfer vinyl is not sticky itself, it comes on a clear, adhesive carrier sheet.

Typically I’ll use a regular iron, although a heat press designed specifically for HTV will give much better, more consistent results.

You don’t need to use transfer tape with HTV, you leave the cut design on its backing sheet and just flip it onto your fabric before ironing it into place.

Heat transfer vinyl comes in almost as many colors and patterns as regular adhesive vinyl, and all the same awesome finishes like glitter, holographic, metallic, and glow-in-the-dark.

Okay, so which is my favorite?

The best heat transfer vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette is: Siser EasyWeed Heat Transfer Vinyl

(available in sheets or 12in by 10ft rolls)

Siser EasyWeed Heat Transfer Vinyl,  Starter BUNDLE

  • The most popular Siser EasyWeed colors on the market
  • Easy and Ready-to-cut material designed for custom garment decoration
  • Pressure sensitive carrier allows you to weed small letters and fine designs easily
  • Much thinner than other film materials
  • EasyWeed offers excellent durability, even after repeated washings

Siser Easyweed Heat Transfer Vinyl  12in by 10ft Roll (pick any color)

  • Choose any color
  • Compatible with all cutters (Cricut, Silhouette, Brother).
  • Packaged in a tube for protection and comes with full color step-by-step instructions.
  • Thin and great for layering. Durable wash after wash.

This vinyl cuts consistently and actually lives up to its easy weed name. It comes in 50 colors and a few different finishes. You can buy it by the roll (12″ wide so you don’t have to trim it to fit in your machine!) or in 12×12 sheets.

EasyWeed is CPSIA Certified lead-compliant, so it’s safe for children’s clothing.

Although Sisler has a variety of different fantastic finishes, I definitely recommend sticking to a smooth finish like the regular EasyWeed until you have some experience.

It will be easier to use and troubleshoot than any of the glittery or holographic HTV, which can be a bit temperamental. In my experience, it’s the best vinyl for shirts and works great with both Silhouette and Cameo machines.

Actually, all of Siser’s HTV is worth recommending. They have patterned HTV (called EasyPatterns) and some awesome options like holographic and stretch.

Best cling vinyl (Test choice: Grafix Cling Vinyl Film)

White snowflakes decorate the interior of a rustic window

Window cling vinyl, or static cling vinyl, doesn’t have any sort of adhesive at all. It uses the power of static electricity to stick to smooth surfaces like glass, plastic, and metal.

Cling vinyl is great for any temporary window decals you want to place. It’s also perfect for removable decorations for lockers, mirrors, and whiteboards.

Static cling decals can be removed and replaced over and over (as long as the surfaces are clean and dry). They’re perfect for holiday or birthday decorations because you can reuse them every year.

The best cling vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette is: Grafix Cling Vinyl Film.

It comes in both clear and assorted colors (check for current stock).

The Best Vinyl for Every Application

I have tried a bunch of different types of vinyl over the years. When writing this article I also reached out to my craftiest friends and polled them on their favorites.

Luckily, we agreed on the best brands of vinyl.

Here’s the deal:

Best vinyl for outdoors (walls, signs, and glass): Oracal 651

For outdoor use, you should use a waterproof permanent adhesive vinyl. The best kind is Oracal 651, which comes with a glossy finish and is rated to last up to 6 years. This vinyl cuts reliably and transfers cleanly.

If you are looking for something even more durable, check out cast vinyl like Oracal 751 (lasts 8 years) or Oracal 951 (10 years). If you want something temporary outside, the Oracal 631 will work, as long as it’s not raining!

Best vinyl for indoors (painted walls and glass): Oracal 631

Indoors, you can use either removable or permanent adhesive vinyl. For wall decals, I recommend the removable Oracal 631, which can last up to 10 years (indoors), and still be quickly removed.

This is the easiest vinyl to cut, weed, transfer, and remove! For any permanent decorations or rough surfaces, the Oracal 651 works great, too.

Best vinyl for fabric (apparel, flags, and bags): Siser EasyWeed HTV

The best heat transfer vinyl for use on cotton and polyester fabric is Siser EasyWeed HTV. EasyWeed cuts and weeds easily, and really lasts (even on t-shirts you toss in the washing machine).

The textured Siser HTV is great, too, but it is a bit more difficult to work with. It’s totally worth it when you absolutely need a holographic unicorn t-shirt. Read all about it here.

Best vinyl for glasses and dishes (that need to be washed): Oracal 651

For any sort of glassware or tableware that you need to be able to wash, you need permanent adhesive vinyl. The best kind is Oracal 651. Yep, the same stuff that you want to use for outdoor signs.

Your vinyl-decorated tumblers should survive going through the dishwasher, but they’ll last longer if you handwash them.

Cheapest Vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette

Here are some tips I’ve collected on how to find the cheapest vinyl for your cutting machine:

  • Keep an eye out for online deals! I like Expressions Vinyl because they are fast and their site is reliable and easy to use, but you can definitely find cheaper vinyl around. You can find cheap surprise packs of vinyl with random colors tossed in, as well as time-sensitive sales.
  • Don’t buy vinyl in craft stores, if you can help it. Almost all the supplies you need for vinyl cutting are much cheaper if you buy them online! Of course, if you need an extra sheet of vinyl immediately, you can head to a Michaels or Joann Fabric store and probably find what you need. But it’s best to plan a couple days ahead of time and order online!
  • Buy by the roll. If you’re going to be using a lot of a single color, it will be much cheaper to buy by the roll than by the sheet.
  • Regular adhesive vinyl should cost less than a dollar per 12 x 12 sheet. Heat transfer vinyl is more expensive but should be less than $4 for a 12 x 15 sheet. If you want fancy patterns or awesome finishes (glitter, holographic, etc), you’ll have to pay a bit more.

If you’ve found anything cheaper, please let me know in the comments! I’d love to add it to my list.

Best Place to Buy Vinyl

(These deals have all been updated in September 2020. Check back from time to time as deals do change!)

I’m always on the lookout for a great deal on vinyl, but even if you’re using the best vinyl for the project you’re working on, you need to make sure you’re actually getting that vinyl.

What do I mean?

A lot of vinyl I’ve tested isn’t the real thing. Importers sometimes lose details in translation, or when trying to cut costs relabel an inferior vinyl as a brand name product.

So I’ve made sure to test many sources and I have two suppliers I currently work with.

This is my pick for the most reliable place to buy vinyl online.

They have a great selection, decent prices, fast delivery, and unlike some other online retailers, they are absolutely reliable.

Second, there are three retailers that sell on Amazon that are completely reliable. Here are the current verified best deals:

I’m always checking prices and updating this section, so be sure to stop back for current deals.

F.A.Q.

What’s the difference between Oracal 631 and Oracal 651?

I have a complete comparison of 651 vs 631 here, but in brief: Oracal 631 is matte and removable, while Oracal 651 is glossy and permanent.

Can you use Cricut Vinyl with a Silhouette?

Absolutely! As long as the vinyl can fit in your machine, you can use it! Some prefer using the Silhouette Cameo 4 (full review here) because it can work with material up to 10 feet long. If you’re looking for a complete comparison between Cricut and Silhouette, check out this post.

What cutter settings should I use for HTV?

Most modern machines let you select the material in your software and the machine will adjust to the correct height, but you can also set it manually using these settings.

Is it Oracal or Oracle?

It is spelled Oracal! But sometimes it gets autocorrected to Oracle.

24 thoughts on “Best Vinyl for Cricut and Silhouette”

  1. Awesome and thank you so much for this thorough review!!! New to this and was just wondering if I could use a different vendor than cricut for my vinyl needs!!!

    Reply
  2. Thank you for your information. I am purchasing a cameo 3 (late Christmas present) and I came across your tips. I am totally new to this, I typically pay someone to create the vinyl for me. I have saved your information to my favorites! Thanks again

    Reply
  3. Do you find it easier to work with and store rolls of vinyl or sheets. I use vinyl for just about everything but I really like to use it for stencils, so I am not picky about the color. I do find that when I buy rolls from the craft store they don’t have any markings on them and if I don’t save the outer cover I can’t tell them apart, which can easily mess up a project. I am looking to increase my stock of vinyl and would just like to know what your opinion is on purchasing bundles of sheets or rolls of vinyl.

    Reply
  4. You absolutely rock!!!! This is exactly what I was looking for to know which direction to take in my first steps in this wonderful world!!! Big thank you!!!!

    Reply
  5. Hello,

    Can you point me in the right direction as to what vinyl I need to get to put something on a silicone wine glass?

    Reply
    • Vinyl does not stick to silicone. Actually, nothing does, but silicone itself. Here’s a site you can learn more about it. It can be pricey, but there are smaller sizes you can purchase. I have started experimenting with it myself and thought I’d share the info with you. I hope it helps. 🙂

      Reply
  6. I would also like to thank Ali Fields for this wonderful tutorial. Believe it or not, I have owned my Silhouette Cameo for 2 years now (embarrassed) and it’s still brand new in the box. I have been putting it off due to fear of not understanding it, getting overwhelmed by it, as I am a perfectionist I have come to realize finally. So it’s time to get past that and your tutorial has actually motivated me to get started. It helps relieve many stresses as it answered so many of my questions. Thank you so, so much!

    Reply
  7. Thanks Ali! I’m new to my Cricut and this helped before I place an order for vinyl (and paper). I want to have a small basic stock on hand, I tend to get inspired at the last minute and need it right away!

    Was the Cricut brand of vinyls in your tests? They’re currently 50% online!
    Thanks Theresa

    Reply
  8. Thank you for this list. I was extremely overwhelmed and intimidated by all the vinyl before. I am completely new to all of this. So new that I have only had my Cricut maker a few days. I started my research, so that I can start putting together a list of supplies to buy next and your list made things seem less ……… scary. This simplifies things for me. If you or anyone else possibly has any more advise or wisdom to share with a brand new beginner that would be greatly appreciated.

    Reply
    • You’re very welcome! The very reason I made this list was I had so much friends who had their vinyl cutters just sitting in their garages or craft rooms completely unused because of not knowing where to start.

      It gets so much easier, the best advice I can give is just start making things! You’ll mess up, ruin vinyl, etc. but that’s how you know you’re growing & learning!

      That you’re already looking for resources & putting together a list a few days after having a Maker is a great sign. If there’s any resources or advice you need that I don’t have an article about, please let me know and I’ll do my best to find or write something!

      Reply
  9. Thanks for this information. Since Oracal does not make a glitter vinyl in 651 what would you say is the best permanent adhesive glitter vinyl

    Reply
  10. Google to the rescue! Well done because my search took me right to your post. Signed up for Expressions Vinyl through your link and made my first purchase. Thanks!

    Reply
  11. Very helpful article. I ran across it looking for a list/chart of vinyls. I actually still have not found a list/chart and it would be helpful and handy to have one that showed: Vinyl name, properties, common uses, thickness, pressure setting…and any other pertinent info. A ‘quick reference’ type of thing.
    Do you know of anything like that out there?
    Thanks.

    Reply
  12. Hi, Thank you for this. I’ve been reading and reading through my online instruction manual and such but had no idea what I was to be used for any project. This has been most helpful.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Best Overall Vinyl: Oracal 651

What We Like

  • Permanent, adhesive vinyl
  • Works for basically any project
  • Waterproof

What We Don't Like

  • Difficult to remove
  • Only comes in a glossy finish

Quick Summary

Oracal 651 remains our favorite vinyl to recommend for just about every project. It's inexpensive, comes in a load of colors, and always cuts & weeds easily. It can be difficult to remove, so I wouldn't recommend it for temporary projects like a removal decal.

Sale
Oracal Vinyl Sheets (63 Pack)
  • All 63 Oracal 651 colors
  • Competitive pricing - ordered/processed/distributed efficiently to keep you crafting affordably
  • Oracal 651 - high quality vinyl made in Georgia use
  • 12X 12 Sheets, professionally cut and packaged